ãæªåŸ³åŒè·å£«ããªãªãã©ã¹ã¯ã³ããæªåŸ³åŒè·å£«è©æ¬ºéå£ããåšæ¥ã³ãªã¢ã³åŒè·å£«ãã©ã¹åæ¥åŒè·å£«éå£ããè«žæªã®æ ¹æºæ¥åŒé£ãïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒã
ãç¥åå ãäœã æšäº®ãååšå£«ãå¶ïšéåãã¿ãªããããã¯ããïŒå æ°ããã
ãããã«ããŠããå解è ã«è¬çœªãããéãåã£ãäžã«æ蚎ãšã¯ããŸãã«é¬Œçãæ³åªã®ãªããããã§ããããã®ä»¶ãäžæ©ééãã°ãæŠåŸæ倧ã®ã¹ãã£ã³ãã«ãé è¹ççã¬ãã«ãŸã§çºå±ããããªããå®åç·çã®ææ®æš©çºåã楜ãã¿ã ãã
ã蚎èšã«ãããŠãååãç¯çœªãç¯ããå Žåã«ããã®ä»£ç人ã®è²¬ä»»ãã©ããŸã§åã¶ãéåžžã«èå³ãããã蚎å ã«é¢äžããŠããå Žåã®å²åã§ããã
ãä»è¬ãå解éè©æ¬ºäºä»¶ãçºçãããçŽãæ¥ã«ã¯ã什åå 幎ïŒã¯ïŒç¬¬ïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒå·æå®³è³ åäºä»¶ãã§ãããã代ç人ã«å¶ïšéãããããã®é¢ä¿ã«ã¯ãå解ã®ãææ¡ããªãæªææžãéä»ããŠãã西å·æ²»ã山岡é¥å¹³ã®ãããªåŒè·å£«ããããåæ³ç¯ã§ããããšã¯ééããªãã眪ç¶ã®ç¹å®ãé£ããã
ããã§ã«ã代ç人åŒè·å£«ãå«ããŠãå šå¡ãåçºæžã¿ã§ããã
äœã æšäº®ãååšå£«ãå¶ïšéãç¥åå ãéç«ä»ãå®æµçãå§ææ±ã西å·æ²»ã山岡é¥å¹³ãå ç浩çãåéå ¬å€ªæãç°çæ·³ãååæ 倧æãå±±ç°ç¥¥ä¹ã
åçºãšãã以äžããã¡ããåæ³ç¯ã§ããããããããã®è¡çºã«åã£ã眪ç¶ã§åçºããŠããã
äºå®èšŒæ ã§åºããŠãããæ³ã®ãããšã¯ãããéããã®ã¯é£ããã ããã
ãåºå³¶å°è£ã§å€æ±ºããã£ãããååšå£«ã®è«æ±ãæ£åŽãããŠããã ãã§ãåŸã®å 容ã¯ã²ã©ããã®ã§ããã
åã¯ããã§ïŒé£æã§ããããè² ãæ¹ããããªããçç±ããªããšããŠäžçºã§æ£åŽãããŠããã
ãåœäººã¯äœé£æããããšãææ°è»æã ããããã³ã³ããçµãã§ããäœã æšäº®ã¯ããŸããŸãã
è«žè¬ã®äºæ ããã³ã³ã解æ¶ãšãŸã§ã¯ãããªãã ããããäžååé³ã¯çºçããã ããã
什å 2 幎 1 æ 1 5 æ¥å€æ±ºèšæž¡ åæ¥å€æ±ºåæ¬äº€ä»è£å€ææžèšå®
什åå 幎ïŒãïŒç¬¬ 2 6 4 å·æå®³è³ åè«æ±æ§èšŽäºä»¶
ïŒå審ã»åºå³¶å°æ¹è£å€æå¹³æ 3 0 幎ïŒã¯ïŒ 第 1 4 6 0 å·ïŒ
å£é åŒè«çµçµæ¥ 什åå 幎 1 1 æ 1 1 æ¥
ããããã å€æ±ºäž»æ
1ãåå€æ±ºäžã®è¢«æ§èšŽäººååšå£«ã«é¢ããéšåãåãæ¶ãã
2ã被æ§èšŽäººååšå£«ã®è«æ±ãæ£åŽããã
3ãåå€æ±ºäžã®è¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšäº®ã«é¢ããéšåã次ã®ãšããã«å€æŽããã
4ãæ§èšŽäººïŒéžå®åœäºè ïŒã¯ïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšäº®ã«å¯ŸãïŒå¥çŽéžå®è ç®é²èšèŒã®åéžå®è ãã®ããã«ïŒãããã 1 1 äžååã³ããã«å¯Ÿããå¹³æ 2 9 幎 1 2 æ 3 1 æ¥ããæ¯ææžã¿ãŸã§å¹Ž 5 åã®å²åã«ããéå¡ãæ¯æãã
5ã被æ§èšŽäººäœã æšäº®ã®ãã®äœã®è«æ±ãæ£åŽããã
6ã蚎èšè²»çšã¯ïŒç¬¬ 1 , 2 審ãéããŠïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšäº®ã«çããè²»çšã® 3 åã® 2 ãšæ§èšŽäººïŒéžå®åœäºè ïŒã«çããè²»çšã® 3 åã® 1 ã被æ§èšŽäººäœã æšäº®ã®è² æ ãšãïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººååšå£«ã«çããè²»çšãšæ§èšŽäººïŒéžå®åœäºè ïŒã«çããè²»çšã® 2 åã® 1 ã被æ§èšŽäººååšå£«ã®è² æ ãšãïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšäº®ã«çããè²»çšã® 3 åã® 1 ãšæ§èšŽäººïŒéžå®åœäºè ïŒã«çããè²»çšã® 6 åã® 1 ãæ§èšŽäººïŒéžå®åœäºè ïŒã®è² æ ãšããã
7ãåå€æ±º 2 é 4 è¡ç®æ«å°Ÿãæ¹è¡ã®äžïŒãäºå®åã³çç±ããå ããæŽæ£ãããã
äºå®åã³çç±
第 1æ§èšŽã®è¶£æš
1ãåå€æ±ºãåãæ¶ãã
2ã被æ§èšŽäººãã®è«æ±ãããããæ£åŽããã
3ã蚎èšè²»çšã¯ïŒ 第 1 ,2 審ãšã被æ§èšŽäººãã®è² æ ãšããã
第 2 äºæ¡ã®æŠèŠ
1ãäºæ¡ã®èŠæš
æ¬ä»¶ã¯ïŒæ±äº¬åŒè·å£«äŒæå±ã®åŒè·å£«ã§ãã被æ§èšŽäººããïŒéžå®è ãïŒä»¥äžïŒ éžå®è ãšããŠã®æ§èšŽäººãå«ã趣æšã§ãæ§èšŽäººãããšãããïŒãé ããšãå¹³æ 29 幎 1 2 æ 3 1 æ¥ãŸã§ã«æ±äº¬åŒè·å£«äŒã«å¯ŸããŠè¢«æ§èšŽäººãã察象åŒè·å£«ãšããæ²æè«æ±ãããã®ãäžæ³è¡çºã«åœããïŒããããã®æ²æè«æ±ããšã«3 3 äžåïŒïŒæ °è¬æ 3 0 äžåïŒåŒè·å£«è²»çš 3 äžåïŒãã€ã®æ害ã被ã£ããšäž»åŒµããŠïŒäžæ³è¡çºã«åºã¥ãæå®³è³ åãšããŠïŒæ§èšŽäººã«å¯ŸãïŒæ§èšŽäººãã®ããã«ïŒãããã3 3 äžååã³ããã«å¯Ÿããäžæ³è¡çºã®æ¥åã¯ãã®åŸã§ããåæ¥ããæ¯ææžã¿ãŸã§æ°æ³æå®ã®å¹Ž 5 åã®å²åã«ããé 延æ害éã®æ¯æãæ±ããäºæ¡ã§ããã
å審ãïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººãã®è«æ±ãå šéšèªå®¹ãããšããïŒæ§èšŽäººãæ¬ä»¶æ§èšŽãæèµ·ããã
2åæäºå®ïŒåœäºè éã«äºãããªããïŒæ²èšã®èšŒæ åã³åŒè«ã®å šè¶£æšã«ãã容æã«èªããããäºå®ïŒ
次ã®ãšããè£æ£ããã»ãã¯ïŒ åå€æ±ºãäºå®åã³çç±ã第 2 ã®1 ã®ãšããã§ããããïŒãããåŒçšããã
(1)åå€æ±º 2 é 2 0 è¡ç®ã®ãååäœã æšäº®åã³ååååšå£«ã ãã被æ§èšŽäººäœã æšäº®ïŒä»¥äžã被æ§èšŽäººäœã æšããšãããïŒåã³è¢«æ§èšŽäººååšå£«ïŒä»¥äžã被æ§èšŽäººåããšãããïŒãã«æ¹ããã
(2)åå€æ±º 3 é 8 è¡ç®ã®ãå°æ¹èªæ²»äœãããå°æ¹å ¬å ±å£äœãã«æ¹ããã
(3)åå€æ±º 3 é 1 3 è¡ç®ã®ãéãã®æ¬¡ã«ãé ããå ããã
(4)åå€æ±º 4 é 2 6 è¡ç®ã®ãéãã®æ¬¡ã«ãé ããå ããã
(5)
(6) åå€æ±º 5 é 1
è£è¶³èª¬æ
0 è¡ç®æ«å°Ÿãæ¹è¡ã®äžïŒ 次ã®ãšããå ããã
æ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒ åèš(3 ), (5) ã«é¢ããŠïŒ æ§èšŽäººãã®æ²æè«æ±æžïŒç² 3 ã® 1 ~ 4ã® 1 0 ) ã«æ±äº¬åŒè·å£«äŒã®åä»å°ããªãããšãªã©ããã£ãŠïŒ æ§èšŽäººãã¯æ±äº¬åŒè·å£«äŒã«å¯ŸããŠæ²æè«æ±æžãéä»ããŠããªããšäž»åŒµããŠããããã«ã解ããïŒæ§èšŽäººã®ä»€åå 幎 1 0 æ 5 æ¥ä»ãæºåæžé¢ 1 8 é äžãã 4 è¡ç®ïŒïŒæ¬ä»¶åæ²æè«æ±ãããäºå®ãäºã£ãŠãããšè§£ããäœå°ããªãã§ã¯ãªããããããªããïŒ æ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒå審ã«ãããŠïŒæ§èšŽäººããæ¬ä»¶åæ²æè«æ±ãããããšãèªçœããŠãããšããïŒå¹³æ 3 1 幎 3 æ 2 0 æ¥ä»ã被åæºåæžé¢ããªãïŒæ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒäžèšæºåæžé¢ã«ãããŠïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººåã®é¢ä¿ã§ã¯ïŒæ²æè«æ±æžãçŽæ¥åŒè·å£«äŒã«ã¯éããªãã£ããšäž»åŒµããŠãããïŒãã®äœã®éšåãšäœµããŠèªãã°ïŒæ²æè«æ±ãããäºå®èªäœã¯äºã£ãŠããªããã®ãšèªãããããïŒïŒæ¬ä»¶å šèšŒæ ããã£ãŠããŠãïŒæ§èšŽäººããæ¬ä»¶åæ²æè«æ±ããããšããã®ãçå®ã«åèŽããªããšã¯èªããããïŒèªçœã®æ€åã¯èš±ãããªãããïŒããšãæ§èšŽäººãïŒæ¬ä»¶åæ²æè«æ±ãããäºå®ãäºã趣æšã§äžèšã®ãšãã䞻匵ããŠãããšããŠãïŒãã®äž»åŒµãæ¡çšããããšã¯ã§ããªããã
3äºç¹åã³äºç¹ã«é¢ããåœäºè ã®äž»åŒµ
次ã®ãšããè£æ£ããã»ãã¯ïŒ åå€æ±ºãäºå®åã³çç±ãã»ç¬¬2 ã® 2 ã®ãšããã§ããããïŒãããåŒçšããã
(1)ã¢ïŒã¢ïŒ åå€æ±º 5 é 1 2 è¡ç®åã³ 1 5 è¡ç®ã®åãã«è©²åœããããããããã
ããæ§æããããã«æ¹ããã
ïŒã€ïŒ åå€æ±º 6 é 1 0 è¡ç®åã³ 1 1 è¡ç®ã®åãåŒè·å£«äŒãããããããæ±äº¬åŒè·å£«äŒãã«ïŒ7 é 6 è¡ç®ã®ãã«è©²åœããããããæ§æãããã«ïŒ ããããæ¹ããã
ã€ãåå€æ±º 7 é 2 3 è¡ç®ïŒ 8 é 6 è¡ç®ã®åãã«è©²åœããããããããããæ§æãããã«æ¹ããã
(2)
ã¢ãåå€æ±º 1 0 é 2 è¡ç®ã®ãæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±ãããæ¬ä»¶åæ²æè«æ±ãã«æ¹ããã
ã€ãåå€æ±º 1 0 é 8 è¡ç®ã®ãåŒè·å£«è²»çšãšããŠã¯ãã®æ¬¡ã«ãæ§èšŽäººãåèªã«ã€ãããå ããã
第 3ãåœè£å€æã®å€æ
1ãäºç¹ 1ïŒæ¬ä»¶åæ²æè«æ±ãäžæ³è¡çºãæ§æãããïŒã«ã€ããŠ
(1 ) å€æåºæº
次ã®ãšããè£æ£ããã»ãã¯ïŒ åå€æ±ºãäºå®åã³çç±ã第 3 ã® 1 (1) ã® ãšããã§ããããïŒãããåŒçšããã
ã¢ãåå€æ±º 1 1 é 1 0 è¡ç®ãæãããã®ã§ãããïŒãããæãããã®ã§ããããïŒãã®æ²æè«æ±æš©ã¯ååã«å°éãããªããã°ãªããªãããã«æ¹ããã
〠åå€æ±º 1 1 é 2 3 è¡ç®ã®ã被åããããæ§èšŽäººãã«æ¹ããã
㊠åå€æ±º 1 2 é 3 è¡ç®ã®ãããããæ¡çšã§ããªãããã®æ¬¡ã«ãæé«è£å€æå¹³æ 1 9 幎 4 æ 2 4 æ¥ç¬¬äžå°æ³å»·å€æ±ºã»æ°é 6 1 å·» 3 å· 1 1 0 2 é ããå ããã
(2) æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ã€ããŠ
次ã®ãšããè£æ£ãïŒåŸèš 3 ã®ãšããæ§èšŽçç±ã«å¯Ÿããå€æãä»å ããã»ãã¯ïŒ åå€æ±ºãäºå®åã³çç±ã第 3 ã® 1 (2 )ã®ãšããã§ããããïŒãããåŒçšããã
ã¢ãåå€æ±º 1 2 é 5 è¡ç®ã®ãã«è©²åœãããããããæ§æããããã«æ¹ã ïŒ16, 20è¡ç®ã®åãæå±åŒ è·å£«äŒãããããããæ±äº¬åŒè·å£«äŒãã«æ¹ããã
ã€ãåå€æ±º1 3 é 5 è¡ç®ã®ã被åããããæ§èšŽäººãã«æ¹ãã ã
ãŠãåå€æ±º 1 3 é 2 4 è¡ç®ãã 2 5 è¡ç®ã«ãããŠã®ãã«è©²åœããããããæ§æãããã«æ¹ããã
(3)æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â¡ã«ã€ããŠ
ã¢
ïŒã¢ïŒæ¬ä»¶ãã€ãŒãã«ã¯ãé ããããããšããè¡šçŸãçšããããŠãããšããïŒäžèšè¡šçŸã䟮蟱çãªã ã®ãšããŠïŒåŒè·å£«æ³ 5 6 æ¡ 1 é ã®ãåäœã倱ãããã®ãšè©äŸ¡ãããäœå°ã®ãããã®ã§ããããšã¯ïŒæãããšããã¹ãã§ããããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â¡ã«ã€ããŠïŒäºå®äžåã³æ³åŸäžã®æ ¹æ ãæ¬ ããã®ã§ãããšã¯èªããããšãã§ããªãã
ïŒã€ïŒããã«å¯ŸãïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººåã¯ïŒåèšïŒã¢ïŒã®è¡šçŸã«ã€ããŠïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ãæããã«æ ¹æ ãæ¬ ãäžåœãªãã®ã§ããããšãææããç®çã§ïŒäžè¬ã®èªè ã«ãšã£ãŠåãããããïŒãã€ãã¿ãŒã«ãããŠãäžè¬ç€ŸäŒã«ãããŠããããµããè¡šçŸããããã®ã«ãããªããšäž»åŒµããŠãããïŒããšããã€ãã¿ãŒã«ãããŠãäžè¬ç€ŸäŒã«ãããŠããããµããè¡šçŸã§ãã£ããšããŠãïŒåžžã«é«ãåæ§ã®é¶ãã«åªããªããã°ãªããªãïŒåŒè·å£«æ³2æ¡ïŒåŒè·å£«ã®åäœãšãã芳 ç¹ã«ç §ãããŠæ€èšãããšïŒäžèšè¡šçŸããåŒè·å£«ã«æ±ããããŠããé«ãåæ§ãšã¯ããé¢ãããã®ã§ããããšã¯åŠå®ã§ããªããšããã¹ãã§ããã被æ§èšŽäººåã®äž»åŒµã¯ïŒæ¡çšããããšãã§ããªãã
ããŸãïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººåã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â¡ã®æ²æäºç±ã«ã€ããŠïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ãæ ¹æ ããªãããšèšã£ãããšãšæ²æè«æ±è ãžã®æ¡åãšæããããè 迫眪ãç¯ããããšã®2ç¹ã®ã¿ã§ããïŒäžèšè¡šçŸãçšããããšã¯æ²æäºç±ãšãããŠããªããšã䞻匵ããŠãããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â¡ãæ³åŸå°é家ã®æã«ãããã®ã§ãªãããšã«ç §ãããšïŒãã®ææãæ®æŽå¶éçã«è§£ãã
ã®ã¯çžåœã§ã¯ãªãïŒäžè¬ã®èªè ã®æ®éã®æ³šæãšèªã¿æ¹ã«ãã£ãŠæ€èšãã¹ãã§ãããšããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â¡ã«ãããŠãæ ¹æ ããªããšèšã£ãŠããç¹ã§ããã§ã«ãåŒè·å£«å€±æ Œããšè¡šçŸãããŠããããšãããããšïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æ è«æ±â¡ã¯ïŒäžèšè¡šçŸãçšããããšãå«ã被æ§èšŽäººåãæ¬ä»¶ãã€ãŒããããããšå šäœããã£ãŠãåŒè·å£«å€±æ ŒããšææããŠïŒãã®æ²æäºç±ãšããŠãããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒãã ãïŒæ¬ä»¶ãã€ãŒãã®äžã§è¢«æ§èšŽäººåãæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ãæ ¹æ ããªãããšèšã£ãŠããããšã®ã¿ããã£ãŠããŠããåŒè·å£«å€±æ Œããšã®è©äŸ¡ã«å€ããæšã®ææãããŠãããã®ãšè§£ããã®ãçžåœã§ããã被æ§èšŽäººåã®äž»åŒµã¯ïŒæ¡çšããããšãã§ããªãã
〠ãããããšïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â¡ã¯ïŒå¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªãè¡çºãæ²æã«çžåœãããã®ã§ãããåŠãã¯å¥è«ãšããŠïŒäºå®äžåã¯æ³åŸäžã®æ ¹æ ãæ¬ ããã®ã§ãããšããããšã¯ã§ããªãããïŒãã®äœã«ã€ããŠå€æãããŸã§ããªãïŒäžæ³è¡çºãæ§æããªããšããã¹ãã§ããã
2ãäºç¹ 2 ïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººãã®æ害ã®çºçåã³é¡ïŒã«ã€ããŠ
(1)被æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã®æ °è¬æã«ã€ããŠ
ã¢ãåèš 1 ( 2)ã®ãšããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã¯ïŒäºå®äžåã³æ³åŸäžã®æ ¹æ ãæ¬ ããã®ã§ãããïŒãã®ãããªãã®ã§ãã£ãŠãïŒæ²æè«æ±ãåããããšã第äžè ã«ç¥ãããã°ïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã®ç€ŸäŒçè©äŸ¡ãæ¥åäžã®ä¿¡çšãäœäžãïŒäŸé Œè çãšã®éã®ä¿¡é Œé¢ä¿ãåºç€ãšããåŒè·å£«æ¥åã«é倧ãªæªåœ±é¿ãäžãããšããã¹ãã§ããïŒç² 9 , åŒè«ã®å šè¶£æšïŒã
ããŸãïŒæ²æè«æ±ãããããšïŒåŒè·å£«äŒã§ã¯ç¶±çŽå§å¡äŒã«ãã調æ»ãéå§ããããïŒå¯Ÿè±¡åŒè·å£«ã¯ïŒæ²æè«æ±ãå šãæ ¹æ ã®ãªããã®ã§ãã£ãŠãïŒããã«å¯Ÿããåè«ãå蚌掻åã®ããã«çžå¿ã®åŽåãå²ããããåŸãªãã®ã§ããïŒç²9 , åŒè«ã®å šè¶£æšïŒïŒããã«å¿ èŠãšãªãäºåæç¶äžã®è² æ ã¯å°ãªããªããšããã¹ãã§ããã
ããã«ïŒæ²æè«æ±ãããããšïŒå¯Ÿè±¡åŒè·å£«ã¯ïŒæå±åŒè·å£«äŒã®ç»é²æããç»é²åæ¶ããã§ããªããªãããã«ïŒåŒè·å£«æ³ 6 2 æ¡ 1 é ïŒïŒåœé¢å¥ã®å°ã§ã®éæ¥çãã§ããªããªããšããäžå©çãåããã®ã§ããã
ãããããšïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ãã£ãŠç²Ÿç¥çèŠçã被ã£ããšèªããã®ãçžåœã§ããã
ããããŠïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶ããã°äžã®èšäºã®ã¿ã«äŸæ ãïŒãã®åŒã³æãã«å¿ããŠè¡ãïŒå€§éã®æ²æè«æ±ã®äžç°ãšããããšããïŒåæäºå®(3) ã®äºå®çµéã«ç §ãããšïŒæ§èšŽäººãã¯ïŒå°ãªããšãèªå以ã»å€ã®çžåœæ°ã®è ãïŒåããããªææã«ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ãšåããããªè¡çºãããã§ãããããšã容æã«èªèãåŸããã®ãšããã¹ãã§ããïŒæ§èšŽäººãã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ãã£ãŠè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã«äžèšç²Ÿç¥çèŠçã次ã ãšçããŠããã§ãããããšã«ã€ããŠïŒååã«äºæž¬ãåŸããšããã¹ãã§ããã
ã€ãä»æ¹ã§ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã¯ïŒåäžã®æ²æäºç±ããããã®ã§ããïŒãããæ²æäºç±ã«åœãããªããã®ã§ããããšãæãããªãã®ã§ãããšããïŒæ±äº¬åŒè·å£«äŒç¶±çŽå§å¡äŒç¬¬ 4éšäŒã«ããäºæ¡ã®èª¿æ»ãäžæ¬ããŠè¡ãããããã«ïŒç² 19 ) 被æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã®åè«çã¯é¡åçãªå¯Ÿå¿ãããããšã§äžå®ã®çååãå¯èœã§ãã£ããã®ã§ããïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšãå²ããããåŸãªãã£ãåèšã¢ã®åŽã«ã»è² æ ã¯ãã»ã©å€§ããªãã®ã§ã¯ãªãã£ããšããã¹ãã§ãã ãïŒãŸãïŒåŒè·å£«æ³ 5 8 æ¡ 1 é ãäœäººã«å¯ŸããŠãæ²æè«æ±ãèªããŠããããšã«ç §ãããšïŒåŒè·å£«ãåœæ°ããçš®ã ã®æ¹å€ãåããããšã¯å¶åºŠäžåœç¶ã«äºå®ãããŠãããšãããšããã¹ãã§ããïŒæ °è¬æãäœãã«é«é¡ã«ããããšã«ããæ²æè«æ±æš©ã®è¡äœ¿ã«ã€ããŠèçž®çå¹æãçããŠããŸãããšã¯ïŒé¿ããã¹ãã§ããã
ããŸãïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã®åŸã§ã¯ãããã®ã®ïŒããããå³ç¿Œã®è«žåã¯çžå€ãããã ãªããç¡éªæ°ã«ç§ã«æ²æè«æ±ããŠããã®ã9 0 0 人ãããããã©ïŒèœãšãåã¯ã€ããŠããããããããïŒãç¥åå çã¯ç§ã®äœååãæã人ã ãããããŠãšã®è«žåã¯ïŒ æµã«ããŠã¯ãªããªã人ãæµã«ããŠããŸã£ãå·±ã®æããããæããã¹ãã ãããïŒããããŠãšããã¯ïŒãªãã§æ¢ããŠå±éºã«è¿ã¥ãã®ããªïŒé ãæªãã®ããªïŒãïŒããšããããïŒéããŠåŸ ãŠïŒããªã©ã®äŸ®èŸ±çãªè¡šçŸãå«ãã æ»æçãªãã€ãŒããããããšã§ïŒä¹ 5 , åŒè«ã®å šè¶£æšïŒïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«å¯Ÿããåè«ãç¹°ãè¿ããŠããã®ã§ããã
㊠åèšã¢ïŒã€ã«å ãïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã®æ æ§ãçµç·¯çãç·åçã«èæ ®ãããšïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ãã£ãŠè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã«çãã粟ç¥çèŠçã®æ °è¬æãšããŠã¯ïŒæ§èšŽäººãåèªã«ã€ã1 0 äžåãšããã®ãçžåœã§ãã ã
(2) 被æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã®åŒè·å£«è²»çšã«ã€ããŠ
被æ§èšŽäººäœã æšãïŒæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšã®è¿œè¡ã®ããã«ïŒåŒè·å£«ãå§ä»»ããããšã¯æããã§ãããšããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ãšçžåœå æé¢ä¿ã®ããåŒè·å£«è²»çšã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒ äºæ¡ã®å 容çã«éã¿ æ§èšŽäººãåèªã«ã€ã 1 äžåãšããã®ãçžåœã§ããã
ãããã«å¯ŸãïŒæ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒåŒè·å£«ã§ããïŒæå®³è³ å蚎èšã«é »ç¹ã«æºãã£ãŠããã®ã§ããããïŒæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšã®è¿œè¡ã®ããã«åŒè·å£«ãå§ä»»ããå¿ èŠã¯ãªãïŒåŒè·å£«è²»çšã¯æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ãšã®çžåœå æé¢ä¿ã«æ¬ ããæšã䞻匵ããŠãããïŒåŒè·å£«ãïŒèšŽèšæèµ·ãããå Žåã«ïŒèªå·±ã®åŒè·å£«æŽ»åã«æ¯éãçããªãããã«ãã€ã€ïŒå®¢èŠ³çãã€å·éãªèšŽèšè¿œè¡ãããããã«ïŒä»ã®åŒè·å£«ã«èšŽèšè¿œè¡ãå§ä»»ããã®ã¯ïŒéåžžå¿ èŠãªè¡çºãšããã¹ãã§ããããïŒæ§èšŽäººã®äž»åŒµã¯ïŒæ¡çšããããšãã§ããªã ã
3ãæ§èšŽçç±ã«ã€ããŠïŒåèš 1(3) ã®ãšããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â¡ã¯äžæ³è¡çºãæ§æããªãã®ã§ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«é¢ããéšåã«å¯Ÿããæ§èšŽçç±ãšããŠæ€èšããããªãïŒæ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšã®ãã¡æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â¡ã«é¢ããéšåã«ã€ããŠã蚎暩ã®æ¿«çšã§ãããšäž»åŒµãããïŒæ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒèšŽãåŽäžãšãã蚎èšå€æ±ºã§ã¯ãªãïŒè«æ±æ£åŽãšããå®äœå€æ±ºãæãã§ãããã®ãšè§£ããã®ãèªç¶ã§ããããïŒäžèšéšåã«ã€ããŠã®èšŽæš©ã®æ¿«çšã®è©²åœæ§ã«ã€ããŠãæ€èšããªããïŒ
ãæ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšã®ãã¡æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«é¢ããéšåã«ã€ããŠïŒâ ååãšè¢«åãè€æ°ã«ããããšã«ãã蚎é¡ã 1 4 0 äžå以äžãšããŠå°æ¹è£å€æã«æèµ·ãïŒèšŽèšä»£ç人ãåŒè·å£«ã«éå®ããããšã§ïŒæ§èšŽäººãã«ç¹æ®µã®äžå©çãçãããããã®ã§ããïŒâ¡åå¿é床ã®ç¯å²å ã«ãšã©ãŸããšå€æãããå¯èœæ§ã極ããŠé«ã軜埮ãªæ害ã«ã€ããŠïŒæ¢ã«ä»ã®æ²æè«æ±è ããæ¯æãããè³ åéçã«ããå¡«è£ãããŠãããšãããã«ããããããïŒæ§èšŽäººããããŠå°æããïŒãŸãïŒæ§èšŽäººãåã³äžè¬äººãããŠæ²æè«æ±ããããšãèçž®ãããç®çã§ïŒæèµ·ããããã®ã§ãããªã©ãšææããŠïŒèšŽæš©ã®æ¿«çšã«åœãããšäž»åŒµããŠããã
ãããïŒèšŽãã®æèµ·ãéæ³ãšãªãã®ã¯ïŒæ蚎è ãåœè©²èšŽèšã«ãããŠäž»åŒµããæš©å©åã°æ³åŸé¢ä¿ãäºå®çïŒæ³åŸçæ ¹æ ãæ¬ ããã®ã§ããäžïŒå人ããã®ããšãç¥ããªããåã¯é垞人ã§ããã°å®¹æã«ãã®ããšãç¥ãåŸãã®ã«ãããŠæèµ·ãããªã©ïŒè£å€å¶åºŠã®è¶£æšç®çã«ç §ãããŠèããçžåœæ§ãæ¬ ãå Žåã«éããšè§£ããããšããïŒæé«è£å€ææå 6 3 幎 1 æ 2 6 æ¥ç¬¬äžå°æ³å»· · æ°é 42 å·» 1 å· 1 é ïŒïŒåèš 1 (2) ã®ãšããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã¯äžæ³è¡çºãæ§æãããšããã¹ãã§ããããïŒæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšã®ãã¡æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«é¢ããéšåã«ã€ããŠïŒäºå®çïŒæ³åŸçæ ¹æ ãæ¬ ããã®ã§ãããšããããšã¯ã§ããªããïŒãŸãïŒããã§ãã以äžïŒè£å€å¶åºŠã®è¶£æšç®çã«ç §ãããŠèããçžåœæ§ãæ¬ ããã®ã§ãããšããããšãã§ããªãã
ãããããšïŒæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšã®ãã¡æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«é¢ããéšåã¯ïŒæ£åœãªæš©å©è¡äœ¿ãšããã¹ãã§ããïŒãããã£ãŠïŒèšŽæš©ã®æ¿«çšã«åœãããšããããšãã§ããªãããïŒæ§èšŽäººã®äž»åŒµã¯ïŒæ¡çšããããšãã§ããªãã
(2)ãæ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã«ãããŠã¯ïŒæ§èšŽäººããšåæ§ã®æ²æè«æ±ãããè å šå¡ãçžææ¹ãšããŠäžæ¬ããŠèšŽèšæèµ·ãããããšãã§ããã®ã«ïŒæ¢ããŠæ§èšŽäººãã®ã¿ãçžææ¹ãšããæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšãæèµ·ããŠãããã®ã§ããïŒæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšã®ãã¡æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«é¢ããéšåã¯å®è³ªçã«äºé起蚎ã«åœãããšäž»åŒµããŠããã ïŒ
ããããïŒè€æ°ã®è ãçžææ¹ãšããŠèšŽèšæèµ·ããããšãã§ããå Žåã«ïŒãã®å šå¡ãçžææ¹ãšããã®ãïŒãã®ãã¡ã®äžéšã®è ãçžææ¹ãšããã®ãã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒå°ã蚎èšãæèµ·ããè ã®å€æã«å§ããããŠããäºé ãšããã¹ãã§ããããïŒæ§èšŽäººææã®äºæ ããã£ãŠïŒæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšã®ãã¡æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«é¢ããéš åã«ã€ããŠïŒå®è³ªçã«äºé起蚎ã«åœãããšããããšã¯ã§ããªããïŒãŸãïŒãã®ä»ã®èŠ³ç¹ããããããéæ³èŠããããšã¯ã§ããªãã
ãŸãïŒæ¬ä»¶å šèšŒæ ããã£ãŠããŠãïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšãïŒæ§èšŽäººããšã®é¢ä¿ã§ïŒå¥éïŒæ¬ä»¶èšŽèšãšåäžã®èšŽèšãæèµ·ããŠãããšã¯èªããããªãã
ãããããšïŒæ§èšŽäººã®äž»åŒµã¯ïŒæ¡çšããããšãã§ããªãã
ãªãïŒäžèšäž»åŒµã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ä¿ãæ§èšŽäººãã®åäžæ³è¡çºãïŒæ§èšŽäººããšåæ§ã®æ²æè«æ±ãããè å šå¡ãšã®é¢ä¿ã§å ±åäžæ³è¡çºãæ§æããããšãåæã«ïŒæ¢ã«åæ§ã®æ²æè«æ±ãããè ã«ãã£ãŠæ害ãå¡«è£ãããŠãããšãã趣æšããããã®ã®ããã«ã解ããããïŒæ§èšŽäººãã«ãããŠã¯ïŒããããã®ææã«ïŒããããã®äœæå°ããïŒåèªã®å€æã§ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ããããã®ã§ãããšããïŒå審平æ 3 1 幎 3 æ 2 0 æ¥ä»ã被åæºåæžé¢ïŒïŒæ§èšŽäººãåèªã®æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ãè¡ãããããšã«ïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã«åå¥ã®ç€ŸäŒçè©äŸ¡ã®äœäžçãçãïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã«åå¥ã®ç²Ÿç¥çèŠçãçãããšããé¢ä¿ã«ãããã®ãšèŠãã®ãçžåœãšããã¹ãã§ãã£ãŠïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ä¿ãæ§èšŽäººãã®åäžæ³è¡çºãïŒæ§èšŽäººããšåæ§ã®æ²æè«æ±ãããè å šå¡ãšã®é¢ä¿ã§å ±åäžæ³è¡çºãæ§æãããšããããšã¯ã§ããªãããïŒããšãäžèšäž»åŒµãäžèšã®ãããªè¶£æšããããã®ã§ãããšããŠãïŒãããæ¡çšããããšã¯ã§ããªãã
(3)ãæ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ã€ããŠïŒæ¬ä»¶å£°æããããããšæã£ãŠæ§èšŽäºº ãããããã®ã§ããããïŒæ ¹æ ããããã®ã§ãããšäž»åŒµããŠãã ã
ãããïŒ åèš 1 ( 2)ã¢ã®ãšããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšãæ¬ä»¶å£°æã«è³åããã®æŽ»åãæšé²ããè¡çºãããããšããªãã£ãã«ãã ããããããããã®ã§ããããšããã£ãŠïŒäºå®äžåã»ã³æ³åŸäžã®æ ¹æ ãæ¬ ããã®ã§ãã£ããšãããããåŸãªããã®ãªã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒæ¬ä»¶å£°æããããããšæã£ãŠæ§èšŽäººããæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ããããã©ããïŒããã«ã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶å£°æããããããã©ãããªã©ãšãã£ãããšã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã®äžæ³è¡çºè©²åœæ§ã®å€æãšã¯ç¡é¢ä¿ãšããã¹ãã§ããã
ãããããšïŒæ§èšŽäººã®äž»åŒµã¯æ¡çšããããšãã§ããªã ã
(4)ãæ§èšŽäººã¯ïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã®æ²æè«æ±æžã«ã€ããŠïŒæ§èšŽäººãã¯æ¥ä»ãèšå ¥ããŠããªãã£ãã®ã«ïŒäœè ãã«ãã£ãŠæ¥ä»ãæžãå ããããŠãããšäž»åŒµããŠããã
ãããïŒåæäºå®(3) ã®ãšããïŒæ§èšŽäººãã¯æ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ãããŠããã®ã§ããããïŒããšãäœè ãã«ãã£ãŠæ²æè«æ±æžã®æ¥ä»ãæžãå ããããŠãããšããŠãïŒãã®äºå®ããã£ãŠïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã®äžæ³è¡çºè©²åœçãåŠå®ããããã®ã§ã¯ãªãïŒããšãäžèšäºå®ããã£ããšããŠãïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã®äžæ³è¡çºè©²åœæ§ã®å€æãšã¯ç¡é¢ä¿ãšããã¹ãã§ããã
ãããããšïŒæ§èšŽäººã®äž»åŒµã¯ïŒæ¡çšããããšãã§ããªãã
4ãçµè«
åèš 1 ã®ãšããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã¯äžæ³è¡çºãæ§æãããïŒæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â¡ ã¯äžæ³è¡çºãæ§æããªããšãã ïŒåèš 2 ã®ãšããïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšãæ¬ä»¶æ²æè«æ±â ã«ãã被ã£ãæ害ã¯æ§èšŽäººãåèªã«ã€ã1 1 äžåã§ããïŒåèš 3 ã®ãšããïŒæ§èšŽçç±ã¯ããããçç±ããªãããïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººãã®åè«æ±ã¯ïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšãæ§èšŽäººãåèªã«ã€ã1 1 äžååã³ããã«å¯Ÿããå¹³æ 2 9 幎 1 2 æ 3 1 æ¥ããæ¯ææžã¿ãŸã§å¹Ž 5 åã®å² åã«ããéå¡ã®æ¯æãæ±ããé床ã§çç±ãããã
ããããããšïŒãããšäžéšãç°ã«ããåå€æ±ºã¯çžåœã§ãªãããïŒåå€æ±ºäžã®è¢«æ§èšŽäººåã«é¢ããéšåãåãæ¶ããŠïŒè¢«æ§èšŽäººåã®è«æ±ãæ£åŽãïŒãŸãïŒåå€æ±ºäžã®è¢«æ§èšŽäººäœã æšã«é¢ããéšåãäžèšã®ãšããã«å€æŽããããšãšããã ãªãïŒ åå€æ±º 2 é 4 è¡ç®ã®æ¬¡ã«ãäºå®åã³çç±ããšèšèŒãããŠããªãã®ã¯ïŒæçœãªèšèŒæŒãã§ããããïŒè·æš©ã§ïŒäž»æ 7é ã®ãšããåå€æ±ºãæŽæ£ããããšãšããã
åºå³¶é«çè£å€æ第 3 éš
è£å€é·è£å€å® éãæãæ